The basics - 31 years old, married with two kids, currently residing in Woodland Hills, CA. Aside from my day job (kind of a secret, but it’s independent contracting), I dabble in voice over and occasionally play around on the Improv scene.

I am simply a longtime film critic and pundit of sorts, especially in the realm of box office punditry. I also syndicate myself at The Huffington Post and Open Salon. Aside from the usual film gossip (not the US Weekly or Nikki Finke variety), I’ll be dealing with box office analysis and comparison and criticism of film criticism and journalism (watching the watchmen, as it were). I will dabble in politics here and there, but I'm sure there are many people on this site who can do that better than I.

For an archive of all of my work, go to Mendelson’s Memos (http://scottalanmendelson.blogspot.com). That site also contains pretty much every film review I have ever written, yes even some of the garbage I wrote when I was sixteen.

I will update as often as my schedule allows. Yes, I'm on Facebook/MySpace/Twitter, so feel free to find me there. All comments are appreciated, just be civil and try to keep a level discourse, as I will make every effort to do the same. Thank you.

Scott Mendelson

Blog Entries by Scott Mendelson

Review: Lockout Delivers Distinctly 1990s-style B-movie Action Goods

Comments | Posted April 11, 2012 | 04/11/12 01:09 PM ET

Lockout
2012
95 minutes
rated PG-13

by Scott Mendelson

The...
Read Post

Review: We the Party Compensates for Its Threadbare Production Values With a Strongly Moral Viewpoint

Comments | Posted April 5, 2012 | 04/05/12 02:44 PM ET

We the Party
2012
104 minutes
Rated R

At its best, Mario Van Peebles' We the Party feels like the director's overt thesis statement on today's youth culture.  The picture is at heart a somewhat...

Read Post

A Masterpiece Then and Now: Why James Cameron's Titanic Needs No Defense

(80) Comments | Posted April 3, 2012 | 04/03/12 08:30 PM ET

It was right at the opening credit sequence. That haunting footage of the various passengers embarking on the ship, with a sorrowful version of the theme playing in the background (a version that inexplicably was never been included on the soundtrack CDs back in 1997/1998) As...

Read Post

Weekend Box Office: The Hunger Games Powers on, Wrath of the Titans falls into the 'Tomb Raider trap', Mirror Mirror Underwhelms

Comments | Posted April 1, 2012 | 04/01/12 04:00 PM ET

As expected, The Hunger Games (review/trailer) again topped the box office this weekend, but its relatively strong hold suggests that it may be a bit mightier than a conventional Twilight/Harry...
Read Post

Question of the Day: Why *Isn't* Twilight's Bella Swan a Feminist Creation?

(20) Comments | Posted March 29, 2012 | 03/29/12 07:08 PM ET

In a classical sense, Feminism is defined as believing that women should have the same rights, freedoms, choices, privileges, and benefits as men in a civilized society.  Under that relatively general definition, I would argue that most rational people, men and...

Read Post

Review: Wrath of the Titans Mostly Delivers the Big-scale, Cheesy Matinee Goods, in Genuinely Glorious 3D to Boot

Comments | Posted March 28, 2012 | 03/28/12 09:48 PM ET

Wrath of the Titans
2012
99 minutes
rated PG-13

Jonathan Liebesman's Wrath of the Titans is arguably about as 'good' as a movie called Wrath of the Titans can be expected to be.  It is...

Read Post

Goon (2012) Earns Our Respect By Respecting Itself

Comments | Posted March 27, 2012 | 03/27/12 01:59 PM ET

Goon
92 minutes Rated R


On the surface, Goon is an assembly-line underdog sports movie.  And yes the film hits a handful of familiar story beats along the way.  But...

Read Post

Weekend Box Office: The Hunger Games Opens With $155 million -- Why It's Good News for the Industry and the Moviegoer

(14) Comments | Posted March 25, 2012 | 03/25/12 12:51 PM ET

Besting any number of opening weekend records, The Hunger Games (review here) opened this weekend with a scorching $155 million.  That's the third-biggest opening weekend of all-time, behind The Dark...
Read Post

Weekend Box Office 21 Jump Street Tops, John Carter Crashes, Casa de Mi Padre Scores in Limited Release

Comments | Posted March 18, 2012 | 03/18/12 02:30 PM ET

There isn't anything too surprising about a well-marketed and well-reviewed mainstream comedy opening well on its debut weekend, especially when there are no new releases to compete against.  Still, 21 Jump...
Read Post

How The Nutty Professor Explains Eddie Murphy's Entire Film Career

(35) Comments | Posted March 15, 2012 | 03/15/12 05:37 PM ET

Pretty much every time Eddie Murphy releases a film like A Thousand Words, Imagine That, Meet Dave or even Daddy Daycare, the critical world at large starts wondering out loud about whether...
Read Post

Review: 21 Jump Street Is No Knock-off

Comments | Posted March 14, 2012 | 03/14/12 09:35 AM ET

21 Jump Street

2012
109 minutes
rated R

by Scott Mendelson

By all rights, this film should be a disaster.  On paper, a comedic reboot of a...

Read Post

Weekend Box Office: John Carter Bombs in America But Is Saved Overseas... Somewhat

(27) Comments | Posted March 12, 2012 | 03/12/12 05:45 PM ET

It was judgment day for the much-debated John Carter (review HERE) as Disney's $250-300 million sci-fi adventure finally was unleashed on paying audiences this weekend.  And the judgment was mostly grim...
Read Post

Going Broke Chasing Boys: Why Disney Ditched Princesses for John Carter

(28) Comments | Posted March 9, 2012 | 03/09/12 08:17 AM ET

If you've seen the trailer for the upcoming John Carter, you know that not only does it not look like it cost $300 million, but it so painfully feels like a...
Read Post

Review: Friends With Kids Sacrifices Unconventional Family Drama for Conventional Romantic Comedy Cliches

Comments | Posted March 7, 2012 | 03/07/12 02:48 PM ET

Friends With Kids

2012
110 minutes
rated R

There are few things more dispiriting than an engaging and thoughtful film slowly ditching that which made it unique and instead traveling down the...

Read Post

Review: Tony Kaye's Detachment Paints a Grim Picture of Public Education

Comments | Posted March 6, 2012 | 03/06/12 01:12 PM ET


Detachment

2012
100 minutes
Rated R
Opens in limited release on March 16th

Most of the ideas in Tony Kaye's Detachment are not revolutionary, especially not to anyone who has followed the last thirty...

Read Post

Review: Confusing and Unengaging, John Carter Makes Avatar Look Like, Well... Avatar.

(85) Comments | Posted March 2, 2012 | 03/02/12 07:18 PM ET

I understood Brian DePalma's Mission: Impossible the first time I saw it in theaters.  I had no trouble following Chris Nolan's brain-twister thrillers (Memento, The Prestige, Inception).  It was...

Read Post

Just Bleep the F*^#ing Profanity: Why Getting a PG-13 for Bully Is More Important Than Fighting the MPAA

(41) Comments | Posted February 28, 2012 | 02/28/12 06:07 PM ET


You can't have more than one 'f-word' in your movie and still get a PG-13.  There have been a few exceptions over the years, but generally it's one 'f-word' in a non-sexual context.  Anymore than that, and its an automatic R-rating.  We can...

Read Post

Weekend Box Office: Act of Valor Scores Big, Good Deeds Opens Low for Tyler Perry While Wanderlust and Gone Tank

Comments | Posted February 27, 2012 | 02/27/12 10:13 AM ET

In yet another stupidly crowded weekend at the box office (in such a crowded marketplace where only one new release debuted on more than 2,200 screens) we had yet another solid surprise, as the low-budget Act of Valor topped the box office with...

Read Post

"Girl Power" Animated Films Used to Be No Big Deal

(44) Comments | Posted February 24, 2012 | 02/24/12 05:55 PM ET

I don't generally watch clips, let alone post them, for upcoming films.  I somewhat dislike the practice of releasing full-blown scenes of upcoming films, as it's purely spoiler material, plain and simple.  But I will make an exception, as posting the above clip gives me the opportunity to rant about something that came to mind about a month ago while I was on a Disney Cruise with the wife and kids. Point being, there will be any number of essays written over the next few months about how Pixar's Brave is some kind of groundbreaking picture because it has a female lead, a warrior princess no less.  But its story, which seems to involve a young girl who rebels against her family's expectations regarding his place in life as a girl in 1300s (?) Scotland (see the teaser and the trailer HERE and HERE).  That's fine.  The film looks gorgeous and I'm a sucker for Scottish music (Patrick Doyle is handling the scoring duties). Alas, I think it's frankly downright regressive that we view this film as a feminist breakthrough.  Quite simply, Disney released an animated film back in 1998 starring a female protagonist who rebelled against society's expectations of her.  Mulan was as much a feminist fable as Brave is selling itself as, and there wasn't nearly as much huffing-and-puffing about it at the time.

Mulan is neither one of the great Disney animated features nor one of the lesser ones.  It's a rock-solid cartoon, arguably stronger in  its first third when it's centered on family drama than its later acts which are somewhat dominated by comic supporting characters (Eddie Murphy's dragon and Mulan's fellow soldiers).  And, as much as I like Miguel Ferrer, I have never been able to buy his soft-spoken vocals coming out of a massive and physically imposing Hun leader.  But come what may, it is a straight-ahead action picture (with a decent-sized body count to boot) that not only stars a female warrior but explicitly deals with the kind of 'girls can do what boys can' messaging that the marketing materials for Brave seem to be emphasizing.  Whether or not Brave will be better or worse than Mulan is beside the point.  When Mulan was released in mid-June of 1998, its female-centric action story was basically treated as 'no big deal,' because at the time it somewhat was.

Yes, it was unusual to see a female Disney character leading the charge into battle and even killing people as opposed to helping from the sidelines, but the idea of a big-budget cartoon featuring a female was pretty standard in the 1990s.  Even aside from Beauty and the Beast and The Little Mermaid, we had Pocahontas in 1995, which featured a headstrong Native American princess who prevented war through a show of moral force. The first big strike against Disney's monopoly was Fox's Anastasia in late 1997, which also featured a female lead who engaged in action as well as romance (while both are better films, its amusing to see how The Princess and the Frog and Tangled both take bits and pieces from that now-mostly forgotten picture).  Going all the way up to 2002, with Lilo and Stich, it was just as likely that a major animated film would feature a female protagonist as a male lead.  It wasn't until the Pixar mold basically took over Disney around 2004  and Shrek solidified animated films as four-quadrant event films that we started to see a run of 'no girls allowed' animated films.


That's not a swipe at Pixar or Dreamworks, per se.  The Incredibles, Up, and Toy Story 3 were all my favorite films of their respective years, while Toy Story 2 was second only to The Sixth Sense in 1999 (and it's so secret Kung Fu Panda 2 was my favorite film of last year).  I would argue that Pixar has worthwhile female supporting characters (Elastagirl, Violet, Dory, Jesse, Atta) in their male-centric narratives (I especially like how the climax of A Bug's Life involves Hopper kidnapping Flik with Atta flying off to the rescue).  But at the end of the day, the last decade has not been a good time for female-centric animated films, to the point where Dreamworks' Monsters Vs. Aliens was actually considered 'a big deal' in 2009 because it starred Reese Witherspoon in a somewhat feminist narrative.  Yes, the decade closed and a new one opened with The Princess and the Frog and Tangled. but The Princess and the Frog's gender-demos was blamed for its mere $225 million worldwide take which caused Tangled to be infamously marketed as a boy-friendly adventure. Plus, Tangled marked the official end of fairy tale adaptations even as it out-grossed every prior non-Pixar Disney toon worldwide other than The Lion King.

Even in the post-Twilight age where The Hunger Games is set to open on a massive scale, female-centric franchise pictures are still considered a risky bet, arguably riskier than they were considered just 15 years ago.  Hence, the seemingly progressive feminist narrative of Brave isn't actually a step forward, but actually a step back, but back to a time when a movie like Brave wouldn't have raised eyebrows in the first...

Read Post

Blu Ray Review: Justice League: Doom Is Paint-by-numbers, Lacks the Depth of Its Source Material..

Comments | Posted February 23, 2012 | 02/23/12 02:31 PM ET

Justice League: Doom

I've complained before about the inexplicable need for the DC Animated Universe features to be so bloody short.  Only...

Read Post