However, Segel is leaving the franchise in the hands of fellow enlightened Muppets revampers, screenwriter Nicholas Stoller and director James Bobin. While doing press for his upcoming couch potato film, "Jeff, Who Lives at Home," the star confirmed that he is not writing nor starring in the next film.
"It's true but it's totally amicable," the star told Collider. "My goal was to bring 'The Muppets' back and I did that leaving them in very good hands... I did what I set out to do, and now I wanna pursue more human-related projects (laughs)."
And human-related he shall get! Segel is focusing on his comedy series, "How I Met Your Mother" and his upcoming films, including "The Five-Year Engagement" alongside Emily Blunt.
And, just to soften the blow, Segel winked at the possibility of a "Muppets" cameo, "I'm sure I'll return in some capacity here and there."