'Extremely Loud And Incredibly Close': Ground Zero Ads For 9/11 Film Draw Complaints

First Posted: 01/20/12 08:34 AM ET Updated: 01/21/12 01:03 PM ET

Extremely Loud

"This is not a story about September 11th," proclaim ads for "Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close," open now nationwide. "It's about every day after." Which is fine, except if you're in the area surrounding Ground Zero, where every day after 9/11 has provided a reminder of the worst terrorist attack in the history of the United States. Now those residents are speaking out against subway ads for the new film, which show the World Trade Center on fire just yards away from the actual site of the tragedy.

“We lost 10 guys that day,” said an unnamed firefighter from Ladder 9 in the East Village to the New York Post. “I won’t go see it. I saw the ad last night. I just can’t. People who live and work around here would be offended by those ads. That happened right here.”

That sentiment was echoed by other 9/11 families, many whom were reportedly upset with the commercials. The ads, which were part of a massive MTA buy, are running on 40 digital panels around the city, including "Church Street at Murray, Vesey and Cortlandt streets and in front of the Millenium Hilton hotel," all locations near Ground Zero.

Out after weeks in limited release, "Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close" wasn't actually finished until early December. An early screening of the film in September reportedly featured an opening scene that included many horrific images from 9/11, including bodies falling from the sky. That has been slightly altered in the finished version.

Paul McGuire, a Warner Bros. spokesman, said the company is working on removing at least some of the ads.

“It was never our intention to cause any distress,” McGuire said. “As a result, we will make best efforts to pull the material from pertinent locations.”

[via NYP]

FOLLOW MOVIEFONE

'FONE FINDS
"This is not a story about September 11th," proclaim ads for "Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close," open now nationwide. "It's about every day after." Which is fine, except if you're in the area surro...
"This is not a story about September 11th," proclaim ads for "Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close," open now nationwide. "It's about every day after." Which is fine, except if you're in the area surro...
Filed by Christopher Rosen  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 165
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:48 PM on 01/22/2012
This thread is FILLED with posters from the great American mid west etc, who have never been to NY. There is an antagonism here, resulting from a perceived sense of superiorit­y. Maybe people from NY have a cultural advantage over people who live in small towns with nothing to do but grow corn. Maybe they don't, but the mid-wester­ner resents them for their superiorit­y, imagined or not. This leads to the attitude that any sorrow NYers feel about their losses on 9-11 is something the mid-wester­ner can pounce on and deride, mock and criticize. "Oh boo-hoo those rich obnoxious New Yorkers are at it again" It's important that these folks are aware that we are aware where this disrespect and derision is coming from, and why.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:04 PM on 01/22/2012
Photos of burning towers near the site, or for that matter, anywhere are offensive. I am complaining about them here and now, even if I don't have to ride the subway in NY. I am not a super sensitive person on these matters, but over time, I personally have found myself unable to look at these images anymore. They are burned in my brain, and seeing them causes some kind of pain.

I watched the trailer for this film and I would NOT go to see it, or rent it. I am about 125 miles from NY, and know of a few people who were killed. That's not why I can't look at it, its that the horror is too big, and no heart-rending story about a little boy and his dead father can take it away.
12:20 PM on 01/22/2012
It just seems that everything that revolves around 9-11 is insensative or wrong or hurtful. I lived through that day and know people who lost loved ones and or friends. Those families have moved on witht their lives ...some have remarried some haven't but they also havent forgotten their loved ones. It seems more insensitive to use the memory of these people to bicker over movies...memorials or buildings. And if this movie is insensative ...why do we not hear that from the families who gave their lives defending our freedoms when Hollywood makes a war movie??? We will never forget but we MUST move on.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:07 PM on 01/22/2012
Maybe you don't hear from them because they just can't bear to bring it to the front of their minds every time it's in the news.
12:17 PM on 01/22/2012
offended offended offended. That is all this country is. Completely offended by anything and everything that comes to be. Enough of the PC bull crap people. 9/11 happened...and people have been making art from it ever since (movies, photos, paintings, books, poems etc) Some of this art is main stream, like this movie, and some of it is in a 13 year old's journal somewhere. So so many negative things in this country have been the basis for art: "Band of Brothers", "Saving Private Ryan', photos of the depression by Dorothea Lange, the Vietnam War written about in "The Things They Carried" by Tim O'Brien . All of these were painful events in Americas past but are regarding as some of the best films, photos, and literature in our history. Stop being so over sensitive and OFFENDED by every little damn thing. In my eyes this movie stars 2 amazing artists (the actor form of artist) and I think they will do it justice. As for where posters or trailers for this movie are shown, the movie IS set in NY, it IS about what happens to a boy after 9/11, and so showing it where the tragedy happens will get people talking about it....obviously as it has. You dont have to go see it (I may not myself, its so sad to see again) But dont get so angry about things like this.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:22 PM on 01/22/2012
All the events you speak of, WW2, Vietnam, were not in our country. We have never been attacked on our own soil, except for Pearl Harbor. Those events were far away, not in our own back yard. this time we were attached but couldn't fight back, We had no D-Day. Also, keep in mind that not just 1 or 2 people had been killed on 9/11, but thousands died horrible deaths.

You should do this: try really hard to pretend your mother, or wife, or anyone you love had been killed in the World Trade Center disaster on 9/11- then reread you own post and let us know how you feel.
10:25 PM on 01/22/2012
I have had family members in wars. I am a veteran. I have had friends die for their country. I KNOW how it feels, I dont need to pretend, so dont be so vulgar. Even if these events were not here, American lives were lost (and as I recall the depression was here). Many men and women lost their lives in these wars, and of course in the most recent one. As well, you bring up pearl harbor. There is a movie about it....and many more renditions of that day.

You think I dont know how many people died in September 11th? Are you that foolish? You dont think I cried for them and their families? Ridiculous if you think that.

They have already made movies about the war that so recently ended. The war that tore my cousin's life apart and took some of my friends. So reread YOUR post.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:28 AM on 01/22/2012
The ads for the film being at or near Ground Zero does seem quite insensitive. But I think a lot of people on this thread (and elsewhere I would imagine), are assuming the movie will be insensitive as well. And though I haven't seen the movie, I really don't think that is the case. I'm not boycotting this movie as many others seem to be, but I'll when and if I do see it I'll watch with the understanding that it is a movie, and the filmmakers are telling what seems to be a wonderful story resulting from an event that is so horrible to cause all of this uproar.

Those who aren't ok with a movie about 9/11 don't have to see the movie. But honestly I don't quite understand how a survivor, victim's relative, or first responder wouldn't enjoy the movie. Maybe it's because I can't relate. But be that as it may, the realistic bottom line is that the filmmakers involved know that there aren't enough people in the world that can directly relate to those who are indeed offended, who WILL go and see this and enjoy it for the FILM that it is.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheSardonicAtheist
Don't Hassle Me, I'm Local.
10:53 AM on 01/21/2012
The title itself is enough to turn me away from seeing this film.
Cinquopated
Your micro-bio is either half-empty or half-full
10:51 PM on 01/20/2012
Wasn't there a blockbuster schlock-fest starring Nicholas Cage as a firefighter (HA!) a few years back If people weren't offended by that and are by this, I'm confused.
photo
jukesgrrl
Hands off SS, Medicare & Medicaid
11:50 PM on 01/20/2012
I was offended by that. I'm also offended by this. It's a free country so people can make films and write books about that day if they want to, but it's still too raw for me and I wouldn't spend a dime on somebody else's interpretation of one of the saddest days of my life. And given you can't even remember the title of the "blockbuste­r schlock-fe­st starring Nicholas Cage," I guess I'm not the only one who feels this way.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PhloxJeana
Never baptize a cat.
01:59 AM on 01/21/2012
I'm interested to see how this does at the box office. I can't imagine too many people wanting to rehash these memories and, these day, who wants to spend that much money to go to a movie to feel bad?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TankGirlz
Lyrical Combat
02:16 AM on 01/21/2012
Well the book was AWFUL if that's any consolation :/
09:25 PM on 01/20/2012
Not seeing this one!
09:08 PM on 01/20/2012
"This is not a story about September 11th, it's about every day after."Not to be offensive, but if you can't see this ad in a subway station 10 years after 9/11, you need therapy.
photo
jukesgrrl
Hands off SS, Medicare & Medicaid
11:51 PM on 01/20/2012
How old are you and where do you live?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PhloxJeana
Never baptize a cat.
02:08 AM on 01/21/2012
Not old enough to have been socially mature at the time.
02:59 AM on 01/21/2012
wow. seriously? that was completely offensive.
12:41 PM on 01/21/2012
Why?
photo
clownprince
I'm tired and it's a lot of baloney!
08:37 PM on 01/20/2012
Ads for this film should not be this "incredibly close" to the site of this tragedy; it's not appropriate.
09:14 PM on 01/20/2012
Disagree. It is a movie, that features a child coming to terms with his father's death. If you fall apart because of a subway ad, you need some pretty intense therapy. 10 years have passed, it's time to move on WITH movies like this.
03:01 AM on 01/21/2012
we don't need to watch the horror again. the movie could have been made without it if it's about everyday after...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mrsbean54
05:58 AM on 01/21/2012
So...you think, for instance, if you were a child who knew your father was one of the many who suffered in the windows of the tower, agonizingly trying to make the final decision between burning to death or jumping with no chance of survival, and then jumped and was photographed as he fell....you would have emotionally healed to the point of being able to watch someone portray that on film?

Most people probably have emotionally healed to the point of accepting reality and being able to continue living their lives, and most will probably never want to watch that stupid movie.

I hope you never have to experience the type of great shared-loss that drives 9/11 survivors to be compassionate toward each other, but you should try to be compassionate anyway.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sol76
08:04 PM on 01/20/2012
It seems like misplaced anger. The film is about life after that awful day. Are the stories of people who had to pick up the pieces not part of the post-9/11 narrative? Everyone offended at the sight of the movie's posters would probably relate to what the film's characters go through. Films are supposed to tell stories that teach us something about ourselves.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PhloxJeana
Never baptize a cat.
02:11 AM on 01/21/2012
Are they? Films are meant to entertain. Documentaries are meant to educate. And there are a lot of people who lived with the terror and the aftermath every day. If they don't want hollywood reminding them, why don't they have the right to be offended and why should they continue to suffer when the film maker has been notified that their ads are causing distress?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sol76
05:28 AM on 01/21/2012
Come on. You can't pigeon-hole films and documentaries like that. You know there are too many exceptions for that to be the case. For what it's worth, I got zero educational value out of the documentaries Trekkies and The King of Kong and no entertainment from The Passion of the Christ and Schindler's List. Some films are so close to events that they become part of them, by clarifying a sentiment or mood that helps people make sense of it. Look at All The President's Men and how it defined the Watergate scandal for many people at the time.

I realise that just by referring to an event or a subject any film would push buttons in people and everyone will react in their own way. I can only imagine how sacred Ground Zero is to New Yorkers and I do not understand why they would not want their pain expressed poignantly as I am sure this film aims to do.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mrsbean54
06:03 AM on 01/21/2012
Part of healing often includes not forcing yourself to re-live your trauma. They just don't need to see it. It's not avoidance, it's healthy....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
innerpuppie
The truth is an absolute defense...
05:41 PM on 01/20/2012
After WWII and Korea and Vietnam some extremely graphic movies were made. No one objected loudly, as I recall. As a very young child, I remember picking up a magazine in my parents' living room that chronicled what took place during WWII to the Jews. Inside that magazine were photos of human skin lampshades, etc. I'll never forget those images; however, I wasn't scarred for life, either. I understand the objections to the ads, I honestly do, but we need to move on. America relives its past to the extent that we become numb to the experience. We strive to be so PC that it becomes ridiculous after a while. It's impossible to make everyone happy with everything that takes place and - here comes the flames - if what is 'out there' is objectionable to you, don't look, just don't look. I am so tired of the tail wagging the dog in America. The majority no longer rules.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LLNYRN
05:29 PM on 01/20/2012
Don't people know that this film is based on A CHILDREN'S BOOK?
And how in the tragedy, a one child deals with it?
If anything, the film (and the book) should be seen as cathartic.

The ads are just a child's expression.
photo
jukesgrrl
Hands off SS, Medicare & Medicaid
12:02 AM on 01/21/2012
Yes, it COULD be cathartic. And if you are one of those people who believe it will be, by all means go to the movie. But if you are, indeed, an RN, I find it hard to believe you think you know what should be cathartic for people and what will bring them "closure." Everyone is different in how they deal with grief and tragedy. Furthermore, it makes absolutely no difference if this film is based on a children's book or an adult book, but IN FACT it is an adult novel that has a child as the narrator.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
erathwomen
12:57 AM on 01/21/2012
It is not a children's book. Have you read it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PatientZeroBeat
Dying since 1962
05:12 PM on 01/20/2012
Fictional movies that take place in this reality often use actual historical events as part of the plot. There were years of complaints while MASH was on. The incidence of complaints diminishes the older the historical event was. I'm sure you'd find somebody complaining that one of the vampires in True Blood was an American Civil War soldier.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
sugarmagnolia
Proud New Yorker!
05:04 PM on 01/20/2012
I actually can understand both sides of this issue. As someone who was at the WTC on 9/11, I too still cannot stand to see the images from that day. However, I don't object to the movie being made.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mrsbean54
06:05 AM on 01/21/2012
I think many people would agree with you that it's okay that they made the movie. However, I think it's also okay, and to be expected, that many people will certainly not want to see it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allen Bouchard
I worship His Divine Shadow.
04:27 PM on 01/24/2012
I can understand people not wanting to see it. It's the complaining about advertising for it that's ridiculous.